I admit it. It’s hard for me to say “no” to a friend or connection request on Facebook or LinkedIn.
Even if I don’t know the person, I feel compelled to say “yes” when they ask.
I know I’m probably opening up the flood gates on more requests to link up, but I needed to get this off my chest.
How do you say “no” to someone who just wants to be your networking buddy, your cyber pal, your Internet friendly?
And the bigger questions — Is it a smart career move to nix certain folks from your list of contacts? Or, can you end up diluting your network if you have too many people in your circle?
It blows my mind when I see people with 400 connections/friends. How can one person know so many people well enough to have them on their networking list? It’s like weddings with 400 guests. I never got that. How on earth do two people know so many people well enough to want them there for such an intimate event?
These social networking sites have become like a scene from the movie “My Big, Fat, Greek Wedding.” Endless, faceless Greek relatives no one knows that well and don’t really want to know…unless you’ve had a few too many glasses of Ouzo that is. (FYI, my hubby and I had small, skinny Greek wedding with 50 wedding guests. Our backyard really couldn’t handle more, much to the chagrin of many of my big, fat Greek relatives.)
One colleague of mine, who writes for a major newspaper, accepts pretty much anyone that asks her on her Facebook account but it pickier with her LinkedIn account, surmising that’s her serious group of contacts.
I also see my LinkedIn account as a bit more serious, but I still accept every Tom, Nick and Harry that asks me to link in.
The bigger the network, the better my networking potential, no?
I figured I’d get some input from a cyber networking expert, so last night I emailed Alison Doyle, author of “Internet Your Way to a New Job: How to Really Find a Job Online” and the About.com guide for the site’s job searching section.
“I don’t think that more is necessarily better. I think having good, strong connections that you know and who can help you build your career or connect with people who can, is better than having too many connections who aren’t relevant,” she explains.
As for her own friend-accepting habits: “From my perspective, and this is because of what I do, I don’t accept every connection that asks. If I did, I’d be inundated with friends who are job seekers who want personal help, etc. etc. I’m sure you know what that’s like…”
Oh yeah, you know it sista.
But how the heck do you let people down? I have a policy not to recommend anyone who asks me on LinkedIn because I’m a journalist and feel it’s inappropriate. But conveying this to the people that have asked me for a recommendation has been tough. I feel so bad when I have to say no.
That’s probably why I never reject a friend or connection request.
Doyle has an interesting approach for this. “I tend to ignore those that I don’t accept rather than declining them or saying I don’t know them, because I don’t want them to feel bad.”
I read this late last night and decided to take her advice starting this morning.
And believe it or not I had a LinkedIn connection request and a Facebook friend invitation in my email box first thing this morning so I was ready to test out my new found backbone.
But guess who the requests were from? Doyle.
I’m not kidding.
Ok, I’m sure you know what happened. I accepted her invitations ASAP.
Bring on the wedding guests. Opa!
May 20th, 2008 at 9:32 am
OPA!!!
May 20th, 2008 at 11:31 am
Eve! I have been having the same thoughts. Is my LinkedIn network what it suppose to be? Will it benefit or hurt me? I have everything from stay at home moms to CEOs on it. In the end I think it is important to stick with the network you have because it reflects you and the people that have crossed your path.
May 20th, 2008 at 12:54 pm
I guess I won’t send you a LinkedIn invite…
:(
May 20th, 2008 at 1:27 pm
Eve, I feel a bit like a luddite, but I still haven’t gotten onboard the Facebook/MySpace bandwagon, in part because of the reasons you mention. Networking is great, but at some point you have to consider quality over quantity. Love your blog; keep up the good work!
May 20th, 2008 at 3:58 pm
OH, come on HikingStick. I would be honored to get an invite from you!
May 20th, 2008 at 4:27 pm
Well, thank you, Eve. Now I will just need to hope you don’t get dozens of other invites from people claiming to be me! I will send one soon.
May 20th, 2008 at 5:19 pm
I agree with your colleague when it comes to the differences between facebook and LinkedIn. Facebook is for everyone I meet in my daily social life or I met back in college. I “friend” people who, quite honestly, I may not even remember. But LinkedIn remains professional. If I wouldn’t recommend the friend to someone who saw him or her in my network, then I don’t add them.
To answer your ultimate question, if there is someone that I feel I need to friend, but don’t want them seeing too much of my personal information (the VP of my company for example, no I’m not kidding) I just set up the privacy settings so they can’t read everything…
May 20th, 2008 at 5:34 pm
Of course, I invited you - you’re very relevant
May 20th, 2008 at 5:39 pm
It’s good to be relevant.
May 22nd, 2008 at 1:58 pm
My personal online networking policy is based on actual connection; if I don’t know anything about you, I won’t connect with you. I usually limit my connections to people I’ve actually met, but the exceptions also prove the rule; if I’ve interacted with someone enough, I’ll connect.
I started opening up my LinkedIn connections for a bit until I saw names and had no idea how or why I connected with them. While LinkedIn is a bit schizoid about ‘connecting with those you trust’ and encouraging lots of connections, I think it’s important to be selective about connections. I’ll forward any connection requests that come to me for other people, but I won’t connect without some, well, connection.
I have my ‘connection policy’ listed on LinkedIn, so if I opt not to connect, I simply say, sorry, but I don’t connect with people I don’t know.
On facebook, I’m a lot less selective.